As a teenager, I was all about Panera Bread’s chipotle chicken panini and the toasted steak and white cheddar sandwiches.

The owner of Mamadio’s is stoked fans flock for his cheesesteaks, but that’s not the sandwich he wants to be famous for.

My grilled redfish with lemon butter shrimp sauce flavor pops off the tongue with a bold, smoky feistiness that hooks you ...