"Jay reached out to Madison and they spent time together ... which seemingly occurred more recently, LeCroy's first message to Cutler read, "Why would I do that." Cutler responded, "It was ...

Explore Madison LeCroy’s dating history ... a few high-profile situationships with stars like Alex Rodriguez and Jay Cutler. Here’s a full breakdown of Madison’s relationship history ...

Earlier this year, the Bravo star shot down rumors of a physical relationship with Alex Rodriguez while he was engaged to Jennifer Lopez Madison LeCroy has ... with Cutler, 38, during February's ...